Economic Growth


Economic growth
Economic growth is a sustained increase in real gross domestic product per capita.
The growth rate of real gross domestic product is expressed as RGDP/RGDP.

For example, in the fourth quarter of 1994, RGDP was 6691.3 billion chained 1992 dollars, but by the fourth quarter of 1995 it had increased to 6776.5 billion. Therefore, RGDP = 6776.5-6691.3=85.2 billion 1992 dollars. In turn the rate of growth of GDP was 85.2/6691.3 = 1.27% in 1995.

The growth rate of RGDP per capita is the difference between the growth rate of RGDP and the growth rate of the population. If the population is growing at about 9/10 of one percent, then the growth of RGDP per capita would have been 1.27-0.9 = 0.37 of a percent.


Productivity Growth


Smith taught us that labor productivity is the most important, direct economic determinant of the standard of living. For the country as a whole, labor productivity is the output per person employed in the work force. In the fourth quarter of 1995, 98,436,000 people were working in the United States, so productivity, in that quarter, was 6776.5 billion divided by 98,436,000 = 68841.68 chained 1992 dollars.

News discussions are often careless about the difference between the levels of production, productivity and population and the rates of growth of these measures. For example, the rate of growth of labor productivity has been lower, on the average, since 1975 than it was during 1945-75. Does that mean "productivity is lower?" No, indeed -- productivity has risen by over 20% between 1975 and 1992; but it has risen at a slower rate than it did during the earlier period.


Two Examples


Figure 1. RGDP per capita in the U. S. and Korea

The diagram shows that, between 1950 and 1992, the amount of marketed goods and services the average American could buy almost doubled. The increase over that period was 97%. For Korea, which in 1953 was a less-developed country devastated by war but by 1991 had become a Newly-Industrializing Country (NIC), the increase was over seven times.


Economic Growth: Visualization


We can visualize economic growth as a shift in the Production Possibility Frontier. In the figure shown below, growth means the economy is able to produce more of everything.

Economic Growth in a Two-Product Economy


Adam Smith's Theory of Economic Growth


Adam Smith's theory of economic growth had two parts:

1) Increasing division of labor increases the productivity of labor.
2) " That the Division of Labour is limited by the Extent of the Market"
We can think of this as a virtuous circle, in which intensified division of labor raises labor productivity, increasing incomes, increasing demand, creating larger markets which then afford the opportunity for further increase in the division of labor, starting the spiral over again. Here is a diagram to visualize the virtuous circle:


Malthus


Thomas Malthus gave the pessimist's response to Smith's optimism. He saw two problems that would break the virtuous circle:

Malthus observed that production requires land as well as labor. Population growth increases the labor supply, but not the supply of land. Labor is a variable input in Malthus' long run, and land is a fixed input. We recall the Principle of Diminishing Marginal Productivity: as the quantity of the variable input increases, the marginal productivity of the variable input declines. Moreover, as we recall from the chapter on diminishing marginal productivity, it is the marginal productivity of labor that determines the wage. Therefore, as population grows, the marginal productivity of labor and the wage decline. Malthus thought this would continue until the wage is pushed down to "subsistence."


Diminishing Returns


We may visualize this as follows.


Capital


An economist named Nassau Senior wrote "That the powers of Labor, and of the other instruments that produce wealth, may be indefinitely increased by using their Products as the means of further production." This is a pretty clear statement that investment, in and of itself, increases output.

Why should investment, in and of itself, increase output per worker? The Austrian economists, such as Eugen von Bohm-Bawerk, had an answer to that. They claimed that "roundabout" production is more productive than direct or simple production.

Senior also pointed out that people are impatient -- people "prefer" to have goods and services now rather than in the future. That's time preference: the time that people prefer is now, not in the future. That limits the amount they are willing to save and invest.


Twentieth Century Approaches


Roy Harrod, a British economist, argued that there might be an imbalance between

The profitable rate of investment, that is,
The Warranted Rate of Growth

and

The rate of growth of the labor force, that is,
the Natural Rate of Growth.
Robert Solow argued that this would be no problem. If capital grows faster than the labor force, its marginal productivity will drop, so the profitability of investment will drop, and that will slow down its growth until capital grows no faster than the labor force. This is illustrated by the following figure.

The Neoclassical Model


Innovation


This is another "stationary state" theory. So what makes people better off, in product-per-capita terms? The neoclassical economists say: innovation. This is illustrated in the following figure.


Twentieth Century Virtuous Circle Theories

Smith understood increasing division of labor as the source of increased productivity, while twentieth-century virtuous circle theorists have seen in addition several other sources, all interconnected and to some extent overlapping with one another and with the division of labor: Modern virtuous circle theorists would all agree with Smith that the government ought not do anything to cause the cycle to be broken, but some of the twentieth-century virtuous circle theorists might call on the government to remove barriers that could arise in the private sector.


My Synthesis

A little more terminology -- my own terminology this time -- will help us move forward. Let's say the work of production is "collaborative" to the extent that the work is divided into different tasks that complement one another, reinforcing the productivity of one another. Then The "virtuous circle:" growth increases the scale of production, which allows the work of production to be organized in more collaborative ways, which increases labor productivity, which in turn further increases the scale of production, starting the cycle again.


Copyright